So scale is where I’m choosing to begin this exercise.
I want a scale that will allow me to fit the large battles (such as Borodino or Waterloo) on a reasonable tabletop but also not be to small a scale so as to have too small a unit size.
So I’ve done some maths behind this. My first point of call was taking all the popular gaming scales and just using that as a basis to see if 1:1 miniature gaming is possible.
If we use Leiozig as an example, the battlefield was nearly 12 miles in length (roughly) so I need a scale that gets this near 6 feet.
But I also need to account for my second factor in the scale, which is Battalion size. A British battalion in line formation of two ranks (500 men in each rank), would take up 279.4 metres. This is based on each man taking up 22″ of room in closed formation.
So looking at the most popular scales of wargaming, we have the following:
Thats some big numbers, but when you do the math on a British Line Formation for 1000 men and the equivalent distance for 12 miles you get the following:
|MINIATURES||12 MILE DISTANCE||BRITISH LINE FORMATION|
|28MM||301.69 Metres||4.37 Metres|
|15MM||193.08 Metres||2.79 Metres|
|10MM||106.09 Metres||1.54 Metres|
|6MM||64.36 Metres||0.93 Metres|
So, we’ve come to our first hurdle. As you can see, with a 6mm scale which is my preferred miniature scale, we can see that there is no chance of 1 model representing 1 man scenario. So what would fit? Below is a number of scales showing the relative size of a British Napoleonic Battalion and the Leipzig Battlefield length.
|SCALE||12 MILE DISTANCE||BRITISH LINE FORMATION|
|1:1000||19.31 Metres||28.94 Centimetres|
|1:2000||9.65 Metres||13.97 Centimetres|
|1:3000||6.44 Metres||9.31 Centimetres|
|1:4000||4.83 Metres||6.99 Centimetres|
|1:5000||3.86 Metres||5.59 Centimetres|
|1:6000||3.22 Metres||4.66 Centimetres|
|1:7000||2.76 Metres||3.99 Centimetres|
|1:8000||2.41 Metres||3.49 Centimetres|
|1:9000||2.15 Metres||3.10 Centimetres|
So we come to our first conundrum. We need to make some compromises. At 1:9000 the battlefield is still a little too wide to fit on a 6 foot table (183cm) but is just about manageable, however the base size for a battalion, will only be 30 mm, which is a little on the small side (if you imagine your average 6mm model takes up 5mm in space, then the battalion would be 6 models wide).
Do we rethink the battalion as the smallest size, and instead start looking at brigades? An average brigade would have 2-5 battalions, which would mean a front of between 1-3 battalions in width (depending on their formation this could also vary). So we’re talking at 1:9000 brigade bases of between 3-9cm. But in that case could we make a compromise of 8cm for a brigade of 4 battalions? If so in an attack formation with two brigades at the front and two supporting that would mean each battalion could take up 40mm in space? Are battalion bases still doable? I think so, but it will require further thought.
Any comments and suggestions are always more than welcome.